Skip to main content

NHS Grampian review: patient safety concerns must lead to real change

This week's Healthcare Improvement Scotland review of NHS Grampian is one of the most serious patient safety reports Scotland has seen.

My first thoughts are with the patients and families behind it. They deserve honest answers about what happened and why.

I also want to recognise the staff. Many of them raised concerns repeatedly, often at personal cost. The report is clear that the warnings were there. HIS puts it plainly: the problem was not a lack of information but a failure to access and act on it.

That is the lesson for the whole of Scotland, not just Grampian. We are good at producing improvement plans and action logs. We are much weaker at independently checking whether anything has actually changed for patients. Actions were reported as complete when they weren't, and assurances were accepted without being tested.

The First Minister has called for dramatic action, and he is right. But dramatic action has to mean more than new faces and new structures. HIS recommends independent oversight measured against outcomes, not self-reporting. I will be watching closely to see that this happens, and that patients and families are heard throughout.

Nowhere is this more urgent than in how NHS Grampian reviews significant adverse events. When a patient is harmed or dies, the review is how families find out what happened, and how the system learns. The report describes reviews that were overdue, incomplete, or failed to examine the care that was actually given. Every review must include what matters to patients, and they must come away feeling heard. Families are waiting for those answers now. I want to see immediate, independent assurance that every outstanding review will be done properly and honestly, that families will be involved, and that progress is reported openly rather than simply marked as complete.

Every board in Scotland should be reading this report and asking itself the same questions.